Hear More Than the First Account
Our agreementI will ask what makes a belief convincing to me.
Today’s devotional
A story can sound complete when we hear it from one person. The details fit together, the feelings make sense, and we begin to decide who is right. By the time another voice speaks, we may already be preparing to defend the first account.
Proverbs 18 describes that familiar moment. The person who speaks first can seem right until someone else examines the case. The chapter also warns against denying justice to the innocent. Listening serves a serious purpose: understanding what is true and what needs to be done.
A second account may add a missing fact, correct a detail, or show a different part of the same event. It may also fail to answer a well-supported concern. Hearing it does not require deciding in advance that both accounts are equally accurate.
We can ask questions that make a claim clearer. What did the person directly observe? What did someone else tell them? Which part is their explanation of another person's motive? A detail can matter even when it complicates the story we first believed.
Careful inquiry must also respect the needs of those affected. Protection may be needed while questions remain open. Someone who has been harmed should not have to repeat a painful account without purpose just to prove that we are being fair.
Our task is to give relevant information a real hearing and let it affect our judgment. We can correct a conclusion when the evidence calls for it. We can also keep a conclusion that remains well supported.
Before repeating one account today, consider what you know and where it came from. Let concern for truth shape both the question you ask and the story you pass on.
Adapted from Chapter 2: What Makes Me Sure in The Conversation Within by Dr. R. C. Titus.
Read the Scripture
Open each passage and read slowly. Notice what it says about God and the life before you.
Proverbs 18:5, 13, 17 · WEBU
5To be partial to the faces of the wicked is not good, nor to deprive the innocent of justice.
13He who answers before he hears, that is folly and shame to him.
17He who pleads his cause first seems right— until another comes and questions him.
Pause and respond
For reflection
What relevant information could change the account I am ready to repeat?
A practice for today
Before passing on a claim about someone, identify what was directly observed and what was inferred. If an important detail is missing, check it before sharing.
A prayer
God of justice, keep me attentive to the truth and to the people affected by my words. Help me hear relevant information fairly and protect those who need care. Give me humility to correct an account and courage to stand by what remains well supported. Amen.
Your place is remembered in this browser. No account needed.